NATURALISM – A DEAD PARADIGM: CELLS ARE PRODUCTS OF A MIND

A major error occurred when scientists decreed that only naturalistic explanations could be used to explain the origin of life and how it operates. Decades of molecular biology research have produced an extraordinary catalogue of cellular details, yet a coherent, unified explanation of how cells function as a whole is lacking.1 Rafelski and Theriot pointed out that2

“The living nature of the cell inherently means that we cannot make the same simplifying assumptions that we typically use for many other complex dynamical systems, and we cannot assume that we fully understand the nature of the laws that govern cell behavior.”

The naturalistic scientific community insists that only purely material, undirected chemical processes must account for the emergence of life. However, this focus on chemical reactions has sidetracked from the fundamental biological questions that needed to be answered. Cells are the foundation of life, and it is precisely their defining properties that require an explanation. They must autonomously grow, adapt, self-protect, self-repair, recycle components, manufacture their own hardware, and reproduce with astonishing fidelity across countless generations.

No collection of abiotic chemical reactions has ever been observed to bootstrap itself into this kind of integrated, purposeful system. More than 99% of reactions relevant to biological systems are catalyzed by tailor-designed genetically encoded protein catalysts. EcoCyc version 24.5 records 1,682 curated metabolic enzymes (those directly catalyzing small-molecule transformations) for the model bacterium E. coli K-12, plus 288 transporters catalyzing transport reactions. In addition, there are many nucleases, proteases, kinases, and other classes of enzyme. Without these enzymes the reactions would be too slow and inefficient. Details like these should have shown the disconnect between prebiotic chemical research and living systems.

Truman et al. addressed this misdirection by proposing a top-down computational paradigm: cells are best understood as integrated multiprocessing analogue computing devices. Daughter cells inherit cryptic computational logic that directs biochemical processes, anticipating future requirements with flexible responses.

Cellular design interpreted as analogue computing

Unlike digital computers, pure analogue processors do not require software code separate from the hardware; the physical construction is the programme. The implications for cells are profound. Cells operate through thousands of molecular Recognition Elements (REs) that can be viewed as sensors, which respond to continuous gradients of Specificity Factors (SPs), which are sometimes called ‘signals’. These REs function as programming variables—dynamic biological elements capable of initiating and regulating cascades of downstream processes. The outcomes depend on the magnitude, duration, and context of the SPs they detect. Truman et al. documented many examples of this principle, with SP effectors ranging from transcription factors and glucose to calcium ions and mechanical strain, each producing graded, continuous regulatory outputs. This analogue character is pervasive: it is observed in signal transduction pathways, metabolic feedback inhibition, cell cycle control, chromatin dynamics, developmental gradients, immune responses, etc.

Furthermore, the responsiveness of REs can be modified. Ligand attachments, chemical modifications (phosphorylation, methylation, glycosylation), cofactors, pH, and temperature all fine-tune the response to the same concentration gradient. This represents a qualitatively richer form of programming than anything available in digital systems.

The logic of cellular programming

Identifying cellular REs as programming variables is a key conceptual advance of this framework. In digital computing, variables are abstract locations in memory where values are stored and retrieved. In cells, REs are physically positioned at specific molecular locations—on DNA, RNA, proteins, lipids, and carbohydrates—where they respond to SPs. The logical operations are directly implemented physically: SP binding to RE constitutes the assignment of a value, and this assignment initiates downstream processing.

This relationship has properties that transcend ordinary chemical interaction. Cellular variables must be unambiguous, are used to communicate intention, can perform operations, and may recursively represent collections of other variables.

A further key insight is the distinction between the immediate goal and the major goal of a cellular variable. The immediate goal is the physical recognition event: a codon identifying the correct anticodon; a receptor, tyrosine kinase, recognizing its extracellular ligand; or a TATA-binding protein recognizing its eight-nucleotide promoter sequence. This physical recognition event is only the initiating step—Step 1. The major goal—Step 2—is the downstream functional outcome: protein synthesis, gene activation, chromatin remodelling, signal transduction cascade, etc. The entire downstream machinery is assembled in response to the RE–SP interaction. This just-in-time assembly and disassembly of processing hardware ensures efficient use of cellular resources.

Adaptor molecules and if–then logic

Cellular decision-making is implemented through a recursive, cascading logic in which each RE–SP interaction generates a new microenvironment that serves as a new RE for the next step. This is exemplified by adaptor molecules. The tRNA is a canonical single-adaptor molecule: one end identifies a specific mRNA codon while the other end carries the correct amino acid.

More commonly, cells implement logic through multi-component adaptor complexes, in which each recruited protein or RNA possesses both an RE for its upstream partner and an RE for the next component in the assembly chain. The concept of adaptor molecules and complexes is shown in figure 1. This recursive, stepwise logic describes many key cellular processes.

The power of the framework was demonstrated through many examples of REs, placed on DNA, RNA, and proteins. In every case, the RE possesses a distinctive recognition feature embedded within a supporting molecular housing, which optimizes binding, excludes false binding partners, and ensures the interaction is coupled to a specific downstream process. The engineering required to regulate a multitude of processes concurrently—in the same cellular volume, and without catastrophic interferences—is far beyond current human technologies.

Advantages of analogue design in cells

Four advantages of using analogue technologies in cells include:

  • Analogue regulation permits fine-tuned, graded responses, which avoid waste and optimize resource allocation.
  • Responding directly to concentration-gradients is simpler than discretizing gradients into discrete intervals and computing separate logic for each interval.
  • Analogue binding interactions—relying on multiple small non-covalent contributions (hydrogen bonds, van der Waals forces, hydrophobic interactions, ionic bonds)— confer robustness to individual mutations. No single point change abruptly abolishes function; the system degrades gracefully.
  • The use of thousands of dedicated, simple, modular molecular machines—assembled just in time and dismantled when no longer needed—is far superior to a monolithic general-purpose processor. For example, up to 10 million ribosomes operate concurrently in human liver cells, while red blood cells have none; up to 100,000–200,000 spliceosomes are active in many cell types concurrently. The copy number of each machine can be regulated dynamically according to cell type, stage in the cell cycle, and immediate cellular needs. This modularity enables rapid scaling, precise replacement of defective components, and efficient recycling of molecular raw materials.

Implications for origins: design, not chemistry

The cumulative force of this framework carries direct implications for the origins debate. A cell is not merely a complex chemical system; it is an integrated, multiprocessing, self-manufacturing, self-repairing, self-reproducing collection of analogue computing devices (fig. 2).

Chemical systems, however complex, do not produce REs that encode intended outcomes unrelated to their own physical binding properties. They do not assemble just-in-time machinery. They do not regulate copy numbers of their own processing hardware. They do not implement recursive if–then logic across thousands of concurrent programmes. They do not pass all of this in a fully operational state to daughter systems, generation after generation.

The gulf between regulated cellular biochemistry and abiotic chemical processes is qualitative, not merely quantitative. No incremental sequence of undirected chemical steps bridges this gulf, because the gulf is not one of chemical complexity but of information architecture—the very thing that origin-of-life models are least equipped to explain.

The research programme initiated by Truman et al. points towards the concept of analogue metaprogramming in cells: the phenomenon whereby parametrized cryptic encoded information unfolds to generate complex programs. This intuition has been proposed by computer science professor Uwe Assmann during several creation science workshops in Germany and will be communicated in later papers. This recursive generativity—hardware that builds hardware—is a hallmark of sophisticated, intentional engineering. It is the kind of feature that, if found in an extra-terrestrial location, would unhesitatingly be attributed to an intelligent designer.

REs are used by all biological codes and usually in vast copy numbers. This enables massive parallel processing. A well-known example is DNA replication in mammals, that relies on tens of thousands of replication origins, so that billions of base pairs can be copied in parallel sections. In a paper in this edition, I argue that the probability of correctly positioning enormous numbers of REs through random mutation and selection is prohibitively low. The paper further points out that evolving new biological codes would require large amounts of additional non-functional genetic material, which population genetics predicts would impose selective disadvantages that make fixation in populations prohibitively unlikely.

Conclusion

The analogue computing framework presented by Truman et al. offers what no chemistry-first model has provided: a coherent, top-down, systems-level account of how cells actually function. Thousands of sensors, implemented across DNA, RNA, proteins, and other biomolecules, respond to continuous signal gradients and initiate cascading, purposeful, recursive programmes. Hardware and software are inseparably integrated. Molecular machinery is manufactured, deployed, and recycled on demand. The entire system reproduces itself faithfully across generations, the result of a top-down design set in motion with each class of original cell. Importantly, complex processes like cell cycle, morphogenesis, immunity, and neurobiology require coordinated regulation of multiple subprocesses,15 all relying on analogue coding programmes.

This image contrasts the view of cells as a collection of chemical reactions vs a sophisticated information-processing technology. Cells are not plausibly the result of prebiotic chemistry. The analogue computing paradigm describes cells more accurately and reveals them, unmistakably, as the products of a mind.

Article – Viewing cells as integrated multiprocessing analogue computing devices by Royal Truman, Journal of Creation. Vol 40, Issue 3

SPIRITUAL PRINCIPALITIES AND POWERS: AMERICA IS AT WAR

A great article by S.A. McCarthy. He serves as a news writer at The Washington Stand.

Every doctrine that Christianity preaches, leftism preaches its own perversion of it. The love advocated by Christianity is rooted in absolute truth, in “Love Himself,” as C.S. Lewis once put it. Leftism advocates “love” unmoored, anchored by nothing more absolute than the weight of fickle feelings and emotions — though, when those emotions are felt, they do reign supreme.

Christianity upholds sacrifice as virtuous — the giving of oneself for the sake of love is the zenith of the virtue of charity. Christ Himself tells His followers, “Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:13). Leftism also values sacrifice, but never sacrifice of the self, only the sacrificing of others. Abortion is the ultimate example of this warped anti-virtue: sacrificing one’s own child for… financial comfort, a career, no responsibility, or even just consequence-free sex.

Christianity mandates submission to the will of God, accepting His design no matter how painful or difficult. Again, Christ Himself prayed, “O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me: nevertheless not as I will, but as thou wilt” (Matthew 26:39). Leftism demands obeisance to the only god it recognizes: the self-centered self. Transgenderism is demonstrative of this: just as Christian martyrs have willingly suffered torture for the sake of their faith, so the confused, self-centered, and self-loathing suffer mutilation and torture for the sake of their own wounded and twisted egos.

Like the dominant Christianity of the Middle Ages, leftism even has its own office of the Inquisition. Those who do not toe the leftist line, who dare to question the new religion’s dogmas, are hounded out of the anti-church. The famed “Harry Potter” author J.K. Rowling is indicative of this. A multi-millionaire and self-declared feminist, Rowling was once a darling of leftist media and political activists. She supported the Labour Party in the U.K. and Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton in the U.S. Yet as soon as she voiced her concerns over transgenderism, she became a “heretic” to the church of leftism, targeted for disbarment from all the institutions controlled by leftism.

Although leftism is a uniquely 21st century phenomenon, its fundamental principles are nothing new. In fact, God has been dealing with the motivating mindset behind leftism since before the world began. The chief and unifying tenet of the leftist religion — indeed, that of all its precursors and predecessors, also — is naturalism. When first Lucifer said, in the words of the poet John Milton, “Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven,” naturalism was born. Naturalism is the belief, the assertion that the creature can replace the Creator, that the peasant may, if he slays the King, rule in His stead. It is the hubristic declaration that “God is dead, I am god.”

Satan was the first to declare thus, in his immense pride, galled by the humility of God’s plan to become a man, to take on the form of a mere creature — “these disgusting little human vermin,” as Lewis called them in the character of Screwtape, a hateful demon. He has declared it ever since, leading countless souls astray. In the Garden of Eden, that was the temptation offered by the Serpent: “You shall be as gods” (Genesis 3:5). Throughout Scripture and, certainly, throughout human history, that has been the great temptation, the great sin: to be as gods. When Moses ascended Mount Sinai, after God led the Hebrews out of slavery in Egypt, that temptation reared its head and the Hebrews made for themselves an idol (Exodus 32). Even then, the Hebrews fell to worshipping the demon Baal, until the prophet Elijiah proved the supremacy of God and slayed the Baalite priests (1 Kings 18).

Whether in the twilight years of the Roman Empire, throughout the Middle Ages, into the age of discovery, or even now in the modern day, men are tempted to declare themselves God, to worship their own selves over the crucified and resurrected person of Christ, to adhere to their own principles or preachings as supreme. Leftism is simply the culmination of this evil, this unbridled, unrestrained pride, brought to the fore via political prowess and instituted in American culture via institutions long ago captured by the prophets of leftism: Marxists, communists, perverts, abortionists, eugenicists, atheists, relativists, and countless other little ideologues subservient to the Luciferian sin of naturalism.

The current division in America is not ultimately a matter of Left versus Right, of Democrat versus Republican, of communist versus capitalist, but of good versus evil, of naturalism (in the form of leftism) versus Christianity, of the fallen angel Lucifer and his minions versus the crucified and resurrected Christ and the forces of Heaven. The war being waged over America at present is not a matter of differing political opinions but of diametrically opposed religions.

One side says that unborn babies, the most innocent of all persons, may be executed at will, torn apart and unceremoniously vacuumed out of the wombs of their mothers; that children may, on a whim, decide to ingest hormones foreign and unnatural to their bodies before subjecting themselves to irreversible surgeries so horrific that not even the most warped and depraved authors of the 19th and 20th centuries could have imagined them; that procreation is wholly unrelated to the conjugal act, that two men might sodomize one another and call it “love”; that sex-trafficking and child sexual exploitation are just the price to be paid for virtual images of increasingly perverted sex acts, readily available to young and old at the mere click of a button; that a nation has no sovereignty and must be subjected to millions of unvetted, unrestricted immigrants.

The other side says that innocence is worth preserving, that unborn children and their mothers must be cherished and protected from the evils of the abortion mill; that children must be raised to think and think critically, think well, think deeply; that the family is the basic and fundamental unit of society, that the very fabric of civilization would unravel without the family as its basis; that love necessitates self-sacrifice, not self-gratification; that nations have a God-given right to defend their borders and preserve the safety and security of their own people; that Christ is indeed King.

This present war is not between two ideological factions but between powers and principalities, between leftism and Christianity, between good and evil, and between God and Satan. “Choose you this day whom ye will serve… As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord” (Joshua 24:15).

THREE PILLARS OF EVOLUTION DEMOLISHED

Jerry Bergman is a well-known creationist author who has extensively published over many decades and who has taught at several universities. He has taught biology, biochemistry, anatomy and physiology, genetics, and other courses for over 40 years. He has over 1,700 publications in both scholarly and popular science journals and monographs.

The three pillars of evolution identified by Bergman are abiogenesis (aka chemical evolution), natural and sexual selection, and mutations. The author of this book finds all three of these pillars defective as evidence for evolution.

Bergman has examined claims of abiogenesis, the nature of mutations, and the explanatory power of natural selection. As in the title of this book, he has thoroughly demolished them. The monopoly of the theory of evolution, in academia, is all the more irresponsible. In fact, it is puzzling.

Naturalistic origin of life assumed, not demonstrated

Bergman is especially critical of Miller–Urey ‘chemical soup’ explanations for the putative abiogenesis of life, not so much because they are grossly inadequate, but because they are not even seriously examined.

“Producing even simple amino acids and functional proteins requires highly laboratory-controlled experiments. Even under these ideal conditions, the very conditions hypothesized to create amino acids also rapidly destroy proteins” (p. 60).

Finally, ‘chemical soup’ experiments very much confuse the issue. Forming the building blocks of life, by abiogenesis, is the trivial part. The hard part is accounting for the information content necessary for even the most rudimentary form of life. Evolutionistic origin-of-life hypotheses do not even begin to do this!

Most ‘neutral mutations’ are not neutral after all

The next pillar of evolution, examined by Bergman, is that of mutations. The term ‘neutral mutation’ refers to a mutation that neither enhances nor reduces the fitness of the organism bearing it. Evolutionary orthodoxy long held that most mutations are neutral. Bergman challenges this and shows that most ‘neutral’ mutations are mildly deleterious. This creates a new problem for evolution. ‘Neutral’ mutations are not innocent, as previously believed. They do not kill the bearer outright, but, because their harm is subtle, they accumulate with other ‘neutral’ mutations in the genome. Bergman warns, “Even mutations that have ‘little effect’ on health can accumulate both in somatic and germ cells, eventually causing major damage” (p. 120)

Natural selection—an amorphous and misleading term

The third pillar of evolution is identified as natural selection. Bergman has a way with analogies. He compares the claims of natural selection with the statement, “The man is rich because he has money.” Others have characterized the natural selection explanation as a ‘survival of the survivors’ statement.

One must make a clear distinction between the arrival of the fittest and the survival of the fittest. The two, though often conflated, are most certainly not the same. The confusion goes back to the very beginning, as pointed out by Bergman:

“Darwin … portrayed natural selection as equivalent to artificial breeding, thereby making it more difficult to refute natural selection by arguing that it was a real physical force. Claiming that nature does the selecting avoids the requirement of discussing the actual factors involved in the causation events attributed to natural selection. Such obfuscation may have been excusable in Charles Darwin’s day, but is inexcusable in ours” (p. 165).

Natural selection does not even have theoretical explanatory power in many cases. Bergman comments: “Human life consists of many activities that are mentally pleasurable, none of which natural selection convincingly explains. Walking in forests, listening to music, creating poems, doing scientific research, aesthetic enjoyment of nature, and myriads of other activities are often not related to survival, or adaptation in a Darwinian sense. Some writers have struggled in vain to explain the existence by natural selection of our human ability to create music and art, all of which involve extremely complex body and brain systems” (p. 213).

Get the book from Creation Ministries: http://www.creation.com